Heads or Tails? The Carshalton coin toss that named America’s most famous Horse Race

The Kentucky Derby is the biggest and most prestigious horse race in the United States, but its origins trace back to a small region in England.

In 1872, Meriwether Lewis Clark Jr, the man behind the Kentucky Derby, travelled to Surrey, England. There, he witnessed first-hand the famous horse race called The Derby and was inspired to create a race of his own back home.


Claim this banner space for your local business

Kentucky is a landlocked state in the Southeastern region of the United States, known as part of the Upland South

The Derby was named after Lord Derby, who lived at The Oaks mansion, which once stood in what is now Carshalton.

Lord Derby’s mansion called The Oaks illustrated circa 1806 source: CADHAS

Lord Derby was known to drink at Surrey’s premier pub for sports enthusiasts – the Greyhound at Carshalton. In 1822, one author described it, saying:

“The neighbourhood is celebrated for every sport and pastime, it affords suitable accommodations for the assembled sportsmen: here are stabling for 40 hunters, besides excellent beds, spacious sitting rooms, and a very large garden behind.”

One of the oldest images of the Swan Bar, dates 1817. The pub dates back to at least 1706 and has changed very little since. Source: Hassell

The year was 1779, and King George III was on the British throne.

Around this time, Lord Derby and his friend Sir Charles Bunbury devised a new one-mile horse race, although they could not decide whose name it should bear.

Local legend has it that the name was decided on the toss of a coin at the Swan Bar.

The race went on to become known as the Epsom Derby.

Bonus quick facts

•  Lord Derby’s full name was Edward Smith-Stanley (1752–1834). He was the 12th Earl of Derby.

•  The original Earldom of Derby, associated with Derbyshire in the East Midlands was created by Stephen, King of England (a king you don’t hear about very much!) in 1139. The peerage was passed to the Stanley family by Henry VII in 1485  Their power base is further north, in West Derby in Lancashire.

•  The name Derby is thought to be of Viking heritage and means something like ‘village of the deer’.

The Kentucky Derby is held every May and also includes an Oaks race. The Epsom Derby is still held every June. They also hold a race called The Bunbury Cup. Queen Elizabeth II was a regular attendee. With thanks to the research of Past on Glass.

The hotel and pub is still going strong in 2026 © Secret Carshalton

The pub is immortalised on the famous Carshalton Pub Crawl poster.

The Carshalton Pub Crawl poster and map created by Lazystuff © Lazystuff.com

 

🎥 4K Video: Hidden secret of South London pub


Claim this banner space for your local business

Login/Register to ask a question or leave feedback.

Leave a comment

Be notified
Notify of
0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
  • Receive a ranking and badge based on your activity
  • Create an ‘about you’ page to introduce yourself when people click on your name
  • See all your comments and activity in one place
  • Connect with friends
  • Sign in or register to get involved

Related posts

Trending today
Themes
Recent comments
Yes, I remember the High Street as it was then. Cannot add details about the building but the shop to the right was owned by Deakin family as 'Gents Outfitters'.…
As usual, great research and well written. Many thanks.
I once was quite interested in local ghost stories and think I read somewhere that there was a mention of "The Black Dog" or "Gytrash" that haunted Beddington Park on…
Stories by theme
Newly added events

Support Secret Carshalton

Find out how you can help